| ** | Crossroads League Indoor | 3:22.22 | Spring Arbor | 2019 | |
| * | NAIA "A" | 3:21.00 | |||
| # | NAIA "B" | 3:22.50 |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Spring Arbor |
A | Behme | Whittredge | Lamphere | Shimanek | 3:31.19 | 3:27.86 GVSU Bob Eubanks Open |
| 3 | Grace |
A | Green | Felger | Brawner | Smith | 3:25.27 | 3:22.03 GVSU Mike Lints Alumni Open |
| 4 | Marian (Ind.) |
A | Bullock | Cosby | Crayton II | Gasaway | 3:23.31 | 3:23.31 2020 ONU Invitational |
| 5 | Bethel (Ind.) |
A | Mott | Simpson | Zuercher | Sperry | 3:20.63 | 3:17.47 2019 Blue %26 Gold Invitational |
| 6 | Taylor |
A | Lewis | Cornfield | Meyer | Sakeuh | 3:23.74 | 3:23.74 Mastodon Opener |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Goshen |
A | John | Kibet | Kibunja | Stutzman | NT | |
| 3 | Huntington |
A | Cheezan | Depriest | Hendryx | Sovine | 3:38.88 | 3:38.88 Mastodon Opener |
| 4 | St. Francis (Ind.) |
A | Sheehan | Agnew | Santoscoy | Bagley | 3:34.65 | 3:34.65 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 5 | Indiana Wesleyan |
A | Miller | Kundo | Cook | Parker | 3:32.47 | 3:29.12 SVSU |
| 6 | Mount Vernon Nazarene |
A | Conner | Couchman | Near | Dickhof | 3:38.37 | 3:38.37 Jessica Starks Open |