| ** | Crossroads League Indoor | 4:15.50 | Jesse Saxton | IWU | 2019 |
| * | NAIA "A" | 4:19.50 | |||
| # | NAIA "B" | 4:22.00 |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Daniel Gerber | JR | Taylor |
4:17.61 | 4:14.35 GVSU Mike Lints Alumni Open |
| 2 | Adrien Gentie | JR | Huntington |
4:22.47 | 4:22.47 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 3 | Steven Ott | SO | Indiana Wesleyan |
4:23.03 | 4:23.03 IWU Invitational |
| 4 | Adrien Howard | SR | Indiana Wesleyan |
4:23.72 | 4:23.72 IWU Invitational |
| 5 | Connor White | SO | Taylor |
4:24.55 | 4:21.20 GVSU Mike Lints Alumni Open |
| 6 | Korry Hamlin | SO | Grace |
4:27.24 | 4:27.24 IWU Invitational |
| 7 | Kelvin Kipkemboi | FR | Goshen |
4:28.29 | 4:28.29 Hillsdale "Wide-Track" Classic |
| 8 | Caleb Beimfohr | FR | Marian (Ind.) |
4:28.43 | 4:28.43 2019 Indiana State Early Bird |
| 9 | Dimitri Margaritidis | FR | Grace |
4:30.10 | 4:26.68 GVSU Mike Lints Alumni Open |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Logan Rufenacht | FR | Grace |
4:31.51 | 4:28.07 GVSU Mike Lints Alumni Open |
| 2 | Gary Richardson | SO | Spring Arbor |
4:34.61 | 4:34.61 Hillsdale "Wide-Track" Classic |
| 3 | Owen Fink | SO | Indiana Wesleyan |
4:34.70 | 4:34.70 IWU Invitational |
| 4 | Conor Smith | SR | Marian (Ind.) |
4:37.35 | 4:37.35 2019 Indiana State Early Bird |
| 5 | Garrett Gemmaka | FR | Mount Vernon Nazarene |
4:37.51 | 4:37.51 Jessica Starks Open |
| 6 | Deion Feldpausch | SO | Spring Arbor |
4:38.57 | 4:35.05 SVSU Holiday Open & Multis |
| 7 | Matthew Hyter | SO | Huntington |
4:41.24 | 4:41.24 Mastodon Opener |
| 8 | Samuel Swanger | FR | Mount Vernon Nazarene |
4:41.50 | 4:41.50 Jessica Starks Open |
| 9 | Matt Wielgus | SR | Marian (Ind.) |
4:41.67 | 4:41.67 2020 ONU Invitational |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kyle Rummel | FR | Spring Arbor |
4:43.62 | 4:40.03 SVSU Holiday Open & Multis |
| 2 | Devin Schmenk | FR | St. Francis (Ind.) |
4:46.72 | 4:46.72 2020 Cedarville Collegiate Indoor Invitational |
| 3 | Jackson Steinmetz | FR | Goshen |
4:49.89 | 4:49.89 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 4 | Kole Hanke | JR | Bethel (Ind.) |
4:52.30 | 4:52.30 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 5 | Paul Bickel | FR | Huntington |
4:53.49 | 4:53.49 Mastodon Invitational |
| 6 | Noah Stephens | FR | Mount Vernon Nazarene |
4:54.80 | 4:54.80 2020 Cedarville Collegiate Indoor Invitational |
| 7 | Justin Contreras | JR | Bethel (Ind.) |
5:08.25 | 5:08.25 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 8 | Diego Torres | FR | Goshen |
5:08.66 | 5:08.66 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 9 | Jose Sosa-Escamilla | SO | Bethel (Ind.) |
5:10.58 | 5:10.58 IWU Midwest Indoor Classic |
| 10 | Derek Van Prooyen | SO | Taylor |
NT |