4 attempts per athlete, Minimum Throw: 43m
| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | KLEESPIS, Chloee | Toledo | 38.90m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 2 | FILIATRAUT, Alexandra | Miami (Ohio) | 38.95m | Oliver Nikoloff Invitational |
| 3 | RUBIN, Deborah | Cincinnati Christian | 39.00m | Blizzard Buster |
| 4 | JOHNSON, Lauren | Toledo | 39.25m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 5 | THOMPSON, Kady | Indiana Wesleyan | 39.45m | 28th Annual IWU Polar Bear Invitational |
| 6 | STRAUSS, Kallie | Toledo | 39.58m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 7 | KING, Katelyn | Bowling Green | 40.79m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 8 | FRANK, Sally | Toledo | 42.60m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 9 | WALTERS, Kelsey | Ball State | 42.72m | Oliver Nikoloff Invitational |
| 10 | SUTTER, Paige | Indiana Wesleyan | 42.86m | Taylor University - George Glass Invitational |
| 11 | COTHERMAN, Natalie | Indiana Wesleyan | 43.20m | 2018 Indiana Little State Championships |
| 12 | JONAS, Emily | Indianapolis | 43.34m | GLVC Outdoor Track & Field Championships |
| 13 | FLIGHT, Taylor | Dayton | 44.28m | RedHawk Invitational |
| 14 | CARTER, Princess | Ball State | 44.43m | Oliver Nikoloff Invitational |
| 15 | DEAN, Gloria | Indiana Wesleyan | 44.73m | Taylor University - George Glass Invitational |
| 16 | OCHS, Madison | Western Michigan | 44.82m | Jack Shaw Classic |
| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CAIN, Lillie | Indianapolis | 45.75m | Bellarmine Invitational |
| 2 | SMELCER, Livie | Miami (Ohio) | 45.78m | 2018 Billy Hayes Invitational |
| 3 | NEAL, Zaresha | Bowling Green | 46.04m | Toledo vs BGSU Dual |
| 4 | STITT, Wynn | Western Michigan | 47.59m | Jack Shaw Classic |
| 5 | DAVIS, Aniya | Western Michigan | 48.00m | Big Blue Classic at EIU |
| 6 | EATON, Taylor | Western Michigan | 48.07m | Big Blue Classic at EIU |
| 7 | GRAVES, Megan | Ball State | 48.41m | Hillsdale "GINA" Relays - 52nd Edition |
| 8 | JORDAHL, Brianna | Taylor | 48.86m | Taylor University - George Glass Invitational |
| 9 | JEFFERSON, Sydney | Miami (Ohio) | 49.09m | Oliver Nikoloff Invitational |
| 10 | PICKERING, Audrey | Western Michigan | 49.82m | Jack Shaw Classic |
| 11 | HOPKINS, Katrinia | Indianapolis | 50.97m | Hillsdale "Very Last-Chance" Classic |
| 12 | PAXSON, Hilary | Indianapolis | 52.38m | Bellarmine Invitational |
| 13 | RAMSTETTER, Alyssa | Dayton | 53.79m | RedHawk Invitational |
| 14 | FARMER, Allison | Bowling Green | 55.41m | Raleigh Relays |
| 15 | MONK, Katie | Indianapolis | 55.52m | GLVC Outdoor Track & Field Championships |
| 16 | BUTLER, Kaila | Bowling Green | 64.92m | 2019 92nd Clyde Littlefield Texas Relays |